Kathleen Y'Barbo's "Sadie's Secret"

In Kathleen Y'Barbo's third novel of The Secret Lives of Will Tucker, we discover there isn't just one William Tucker - there are two, the identical twins William Jefferson and William John.  Upon being released from a year of wrongful imprisonment, it could be said that British detective William Jefferson Tucker has some unresolved issues with his criminal twin brother, especially since John deliberately put him there in the first place after managing to convince the powers that be that Jefferson was the real criminal and he (William John) was the innocent.  Pretty Pinkerton agent Sadie Callum knows the truth, so she springs Jefferson, but she is mighty tired of being on the Tucker Case when what she really wants is to be on a case involving international art fraud.  However, soon it appears that two are mixed up somehow - is it only because Jefferson was the British agent on the case before he was incarcerated?  Or are he and John really in cahoots, trading off on their good twin/bad twin reputation to swindle them all?

Once again it is Y'Barbo's talent with spectacular secondary characters that really makes the book.  Sadie's father, her mother, her Uncle Penn - there's more to each of them than meets the eye.  Even the bit parts, like Jefferson's spunky granny, play an important and memorable role in the plot.  Considering that Sadie has five brothers and that they are relatively minor characters, I was impressed by how distinct the author was able to make them - they were definitely individuals, not just a unit. 

One overarching theme of the series is the importance of family, and it is the pivot point for the main characters in this book.  No matter how annoying, meddlesome, or untrustworthy they are, one always wants to believe the best in one's family, to give them a chance to do things right.  As much as Jefferson believes his brother deserves to be in jail - and he is more than willing to put him there himself - he still falls for his brother's cons, always hoping that he'll finally choose the path of right.  Sadie has a wonderful family; in spite of their overprotective,  meddling ways, you can tell how much they love her, and just how much she loves and respects them back.  Even though she often feels hemmed in by them, and though she does not always agree with them, their opinions factor heavily in her decisions. 

While I very much enjoyed the first two of the series, this one was my favorite.  Watching two detectives practice their trade on each other to worm out information and manipulate behavior was quite amusing.  Much of the story is fun and romantic, but there is also discussion of serious topics, and a time in which my eyes did not remain precisely dry.  It is a novel not of revenge, but of truth, trust, and restoration. 

Thank you Harvest House and Netgalley for providing a free, advance e-copy for the purpose of review.  I was not required to make it positive; all opinions expressed are my own.


The Secret Lives of Will Tucker begins with Flora's Wish, followed by Millie's Treasure, and is concluded in Sadie's Secret. 

"Millie's Treasure" by Kathleen Y'Barbo

In Kathleen Y'Barbo's novel Millie's Treasure, which follows Flora's Wish in the series of The Secret Lives of Will Tucker, Will Tucker is once again out of jail and pulling his finacé scam on wealthy young women, swindling them out of their jewels; this time, his eyes are set on Mildred Cope, the bluestocking daughter of a southern gentleman.  Millie's father is not the most pleasant of men - in fact, she is planning on marrying her Sir William Trueck for the sole purpose of escaping her father, who has forbidden her studies in cryptology and other scientific research.  Pinkerton agent Kyle Russell has been momentarily pulled off of the Will Tucker case to search for lost Confederate gold, and while experimenting with his latest invention encounters the lovely Millie.  Though off to a mildly rocky start, they forge a bond over their love of science, and Millie has a puzzle she needs Kyle's help to solve.  Despite what Kyle's heart tells him, he cannot be sure of the lovely southern belle - is Millie connected to the missing treasure?  And has she joined forces with the notorious Will Tucker to find it?

This is not your typical historical novel; though the setting is well researched regarding time and place, it actually borders on fantasy, based on legend rather than historical fact.  The tales surrounding Jean Lafitte and his treasure are fascinating; I had no idea that there were connections (tenuous though they may be) between Lafitte and the stories of hidden Confederate gold.  Even if it is not necessarily how history went, it is fun to hear them and wonder how close they are to the truth.  The steam punk aspect - the inclusion of inventions that have not yet been patented and quite possibly not completely invented - also adds to the fantastic feel of the novel.  Really, how romantic would it be to have the gentleman of your dreams appear in your window, ready to whisk you off on a romantic flight beneath the stars?

While it is a light-hearted novel,  Millie's Treasure does touch on a couple serious issues - Millie's father, wracked by grief and guilt, has pulled away from his only surviving child, feeling guilt for her mother's and sisters' deaths every time he looks at her, afraid to show his love.  Millie must fight to find a way to be herself in a society and under the authority of those who disapprove of her interests and desires.  It is a fun, clean, read, full of romance and adventure.  4 out of 5 stars

"Fired Up" by Mary Connealy

Fired Up in her Trouble in Texas series picks up right where Mary Connealy left off in Swept Away.  Dare Riker, self-proclaimed doctor based on his experience patching people up in Andersonville prison during the Civil War, still has a thing for the lovely Glynna Greer, who, recently widowed from her abusive polecat of a husband, rather likes him back.  The problem is, she's had two bad husbands in a row, and her two children, her maturing son Paul especially, are not keen on a third.  In fact, Paul has threatened Dare's life on occasion, which might not normally be taken seriously, except that there is that man-made avalanche that almost killed him, followed by a fire, and topped by a stabbing.  All this on top of Glynna's cooking at her diner, which, while it hasn't actually killed anyone yet, has significantly increased Dare's doctoring business.  Can Dare live long enough to make peace with the kids so Glynna will marry him? 

One of the best but hardest parts of this story is the relationship between Dare and Paul.  Dare is trying to teach Paul that there are good men in the world who respect women, men, and children alike; in an effort to be a good role model, he tries to spend more time with Paul by inviting him hunting, encouraging his help with his doctor practice, and generally including him with the men.  However, every step forward seems to end right back where he started, with an angry, sullen young man.  Paul is very protective of his mother; when he sees that Dare likes his mother, he feels like Dare's overtures of friendship are just a ploy to get at his mom, so he again hardens his heart against him.  Dare is a good example of what a man should do in the situation: he is friendly and makes an effort to include Paul without forcing him one way or the other, but he doesn't hesitate to lay down the law when he needs to.  That strength to say no, to temper discipline with compassion, while unappealing to Paul, is, I think, what will eventually lead to a good relationship between the two. 

I like - but am a bit frustrated - that Connealy has set up the next book in the series by giving a little more background on Vince and introducing Jonas' reforming sister Tina.  It's fun to get a taste of the next book, but if only it were not so long until it comes out!  There's a bit less talk of God in Fired Up than in many of Connealy's previous novels - it is basically limited to some discussion on forgiveness at the end - which was a little disappointing.  However, like usual, she writes a great comedy.  This one has a bit more mystery than usual, since it is anyone's guess who is trying to bump Dare off.  A highly amusing book!  4 out of 5 stars

Thank you to Bethany House for providing a free copy of this novel for the purpose of review; I was not required to make it positive, and all opinions are my own.

Trouble in Texas
Prequel: "Closer than Brothers: Surviving Andersonville" (novella)
1. Swept Away
2. Fired Up
3. Stuck Together

"Runaway Bride" (follows Trouble in Texas and Kincaid Brides series; from the novella collection With This Ring?)

"The Tangled Ties that Bind" (follows Trouble in Texas and Kincaid Brides series; from the novella collection Hearts Entwined)

Olivia Newport's "The Invention of Sarah Cummings"

Set in 1890's Chicago, Olivia Newport's The Invention of Sarah Cummings follows a young parlor maid as she invents for herself a role in upper class society.  Orphaned as a child and sent into service as a teenager, Sarah has become an accomplished seamstress but longs for a life of ease.  In a spur of the moment decision, Sarah invents for herself a new name - Serena Cuthbert - along with a full, affluent past to sneak her way into society and a wealthy marriage.  However, her new life still has to be sandwiched in between her duties as a maid and her obligation to teach sewing classes for the girls at the orphanage where she grew up, and it becomes harder and harder to keep her servile life secret from her friends and beau in society. 

I do not completely dislike Sarah, but due to her choices and the motives behind them, it is also hard to actually like her.  If there were anything noble about her deception, it would be easier, but it is purely for her own personal gain that she passes herself off as a socialite.  Creating, owning, and wearing fancy dresses is acceptable; creating a false life with the full intention of perpetuating it through marriage is not.  I also had a hard time understanding her fantasy - she can appear to be a wealthy lady by her dress and talk, but the moment they find out the truth, where will she be?  Back to being just a maid, quite possibly sacked, and likely branded a liar.  In the city where she was born and raised, where acquaintances abound, there is too miniscule a chance of pulling off her deception even long enough to become engaged, let alone marry. 

Newport writes an incredibly rich historical novel, in which clearly a significant amount of research was involved.  Invention involves a lot of the political history of the time, including the William McKinley vs William Jennings Bryan debates and presidential election, at a time when America was moving toward leaving the gold standard for currency.  Her take on the upstairs-downstairs roles is also well written, and in spite of Sarah's blurred view of the lines, it is still clearly a very real divide -  the wealthy can choose to "work" by occasionally helping with charities, but they are not friends with nor do they marry those of the working class.  Newport's appreciation for the perfection involved in service comes through in Sarah's tendency to notice the hard work of other servants while she is pretending to be Serena Cuthbert. 

The novel was not exactly what I had anticipated.  Having never read any of Newport's novels before, I was expecting something a little more lighthearted and romantic, based on the title and description; this, however, is decidedly on the reserved side, with a greater emphasis on the history than the romance.  Since the relationship between Sarah and Simon is not a strong focus of the book, it seems a bit rushed in the end when Sara is finally willing to take a chance on him.  Also, I am uncertain as to whether or not she learns anything spiritually; she learns to accept herself and chooses to make things right with Simon, but I do not feel she is any closer to God personally at the end of the book than at the beginning.  Given that, along with how difficult it was to care for the main character, I give this book 3 stars.  While it is the third book of a series, I had no problem following the story.  I would still like to read the first two novels of the series, though, as I liked the writing style and strong historical basis. 

I received a free e-copy of this novel from Revell via Netgalley for the purpose of review; all opinions expressed are my own, and I was not required to make my review positive.


Avenue of Dreams
The Pursuit of Lucy Banning
The Dilemma of Charlotte Farrow
The Invention of Sarah Cummings

Irene Hannon's "Trapped" - true suspense!

Wow.  Talk about suspense.  Irene Hannon's Trapped is not a mystery-suspense, where some of the thrill is watered down in distracting the reader with red herrings until the final coup reveals the villain; this is a hard core, Alfred Hitchcock-style thriller, where we are privy to everything that is going on - from the villain's thoughts to the victim's to the detective's to that of the girl being used by the villain - watching seemingly innocent actions twist into something both terrible and terrifying.

Hannon's tale begins with the disappearance of Laura Griffith's sixteen-year-old half-sister, Darcy, who, fed up with rules, takes off into a winter storm leaving behind only a short note to say that she has gone.  Not getting the response she wants from the local police, Laura turns to Phoenix Inc, a private investigative agency run by three men formerly in law-enforcement, including James Devlin, ex-ATF agent.  Dev is quite taken with Laura, and, knowing how quickly teens on the street end up in prostitution and drugs, he throws himself into the investigation, hoping the multi-day storm is enough to keep Darcy from escaping St. Louis, at which point her chances of being found would grow notably slimmer. However, as the days stretch on, the trail grows colder, and their suspicions grow stronger that something sinister has happened to her. 

While the description of the book leads one to believe that Dev and Laura are the focus of the novel, it is actually through Darcy's and the villain's point of view that we see most of the suspense.  Without them, it would be a long, boring search (and just another mystery-suspense cross) before the intense finale.  Hannon, however, weaves the suspense surrounding Darcy with the romance and tough PI work of Dev and Laura to form a well balanced novel.  It starts out ominous and builds steadily from there, not remotely suffering from the middle-of-the-book-slump that so often plagues the genre. 

Like Hitchcock's tradition of interspersing humor to cut the tension periodically and thus intensify the suspense without overdosing the audience, Hannon includes plenty of ribbing and good natured banter between employees of the Phoenix Inc, being a company formed by good friends.  The developing romance, too, provides relief and a necessary humanity to the novel so that we care what happens to Dev and Laura (in addition to Darcy, with whom our sympathies instinctively lie, being the victim); we see their motivations, their regrets, their uncertainties, and we watch them break down walls that they had erected over the years.  In Darcy we see the most change: from a defiant youth to a broken, frightened girl, crying out to God, to an imperfect but loving sister who no longer takes life for granted. 

While I have enjoyed all of Hannon's books, this one has surpassed them all, reaching even beyond what I expected from Hannon's expert hand at the genre. While the romance may happen incredibly quickly and the Christian message be not as strong as in other novels, this is a clean, supreme example of what a suspense should be.  5 out of 5 stars!

Thank you Revell and Netgalley for providing me a free e-copy of this novel for the purpose of review; I was not required to make it positive.  

Private Justice
1. Vanished
2. Trapped
3. Deceived

Christian WWII Books and Authors

Having been on a bit of a WWII kick lately, I felt like compiling a selection of Christian WWII fiction.  Just so you know, there's a lot more out there than I thought!  I severely doubt this is a comprehensive list, but I have tried to be thorough as possible.

* indicates I have read it

Lynn Austin

A Woman's Place (2006)*
While We're Far Apart (2010)

Austin's works describe life on the Home Front for women, children, and men whose loved ones have joined the war.

Kate Breslin
For Such a Time (2014)*

A retelling of Esther, focusing on a Czechoslovakian transit camp

Sigmund Brouwer
Thief of Glory (2014)*
A gritty novel in the Pacific, in a Japanese internment camp


Kristy Cambron
Hidden Masterpiece
1. The Butterfly and the Violin (2014)*
2. A Sparrow in Terezin (2015)*

The present and the past intertwine in these books which take place both in WWII and the present.

Jack Cavanaugh
Songs in the Night
1. While Mortals Sleep (2001)
2. His Watchful Eye (2002)
3. Above All Earthly Powers (2004)

Eva Marie Everson
The One True Love of Alice-Ann (2017)*

Cathy Gohlke
Saving Amelie (2014)*
Secrets She Kept (2015)*
Until We Find Home (2018)*

Gohlke specializes in profound stories of Europe's role in the war--the beautiful, the ugly, the praiseworthy, the unspeakable--and wraps them in compelling narratives that shine God's truth from a dark place.

Tricia Goyer
WWII Liberators
From Dust and Ashes: A Story of Liberation (2003)
Night Song: A Story of Sacrifice (2004)
Dawn of a Thousand Nights: A Story of Honor (2005)
Arms of Deliverance: A Story of Promise (2006)

Love Finds You in Victory Heights, Washington (2010)

Songbird Under a German Moon (2010) (Post-WWII Germany)

The London Chronicles
1. A Secret Courage (2017)*
2. A Daring Escape (2018)

Tricia Goyer and Mike Yorkey 
The Swiss Courier (2009)*
Chasing Mona Lisa (2012)*

Swiss agents star in these two novels as they first smuggle an important scientist out of Germany and then race through France to rescue the Mona Lisa from German hands.  Suspense and adventure are the main focus, though there is still a touch of romance.

Tracy Groot
Flame of Resistance (2012)*

A tale of French resistance--and retelling of the story of Rahab--in the final weeks leading up to D-Day


Judith Pella
Daughters of Fortune
1. Written on the Wind (2001)
2. Somewhere a Song (2002)
3. Toward the Sunrise (2003)
4. Homeward my Heart (2004)

Cara Putman 
Stars in the Night (2010)*
Shadowed by Grace (2013)

Historical suspense, first on the Home Front in Hollywood and then in Italy. 


Sarah Sundin
Wings of Glory 
1. A Distant Melody (2010)*
2. A Memory Between Us (2010)*
3. Blue Skies Tomorrow (2011)*

Focusing on the Novak family of California, all three sons have joined the air force and battle the Germans over in Europe. 

Wings of the Nightingale
1. With Every Letter (2012)*
2. On Distant Shores (2013)*
3. In Perfect Time (2014)*
 

Just as the Civil War was the start of a new era for nurses - women as nurses in hospitals! - so WWII put them in a new place: on board aircraft for medical evacuations.  While injured men were being evacuated to hospitals and out of harm's way, nurses tended them to keep them alive on the flight to safety, sometimes hours away.  Sundin's series follows three different flight nurses and their experiences as some of the first women in the air - from the intense training, to the prejudice received, to their incredible mark on history. 


Waves of Freedom 
1. Through Waters Deep (2015)*
2. Anchor in the Storm (2016)*
3. When Tides Turn (2017)*

Sundin's next series follows the Avery family, with three naval officers from Boston fighting in the Atlantic during the early years of WWII, and the three women  - a shipyard worker, a pharmacist, and a WAVE (Women Accepted for Volunteer Emergency Service) - with whom they fall in love. 

Sunrise at Normandy
1. The Sea Before Us (2018)*
2. The Sky Above Us (2019)
3. The Land Beneath Us (2020)

Three estranged brothers--in three different branches of the service--some together on the shores of Normandy.

Bodie and Brock Thoene
Zion Covenant
1. Vienna Prelude (1989)
2. Prague Counterpoint (1989)
3. Munich Signature (1990)
4. Jerusalem Interlude (1990)
5. Danzig Passage (1991)
6. Warsaw Requiem (1991)
7. London Refrain (2005)
8. Paris Encore (2005)
9. Dunkirk Crescendo (2005)

Liz Tolsma
Women of Courage
1. Snow on the Tulips (2013)*
2. Daisies are Forever (2014)*
3. Remember the Lilies (2015)

Dan Walsh
The Unfinished Gift (2009)
The Homecoming (2010)
The Discovery (2012)

The first two take place on the Home Front in WWII, while The Discovery is actually a contemporary novel about a young man finding his deceased grandfather's manuscript to a WWII love story, and what he learns through the tale. 

Susan May Warren
Sons of Thunder (2010)
Nightingale (2010)*

Nightingale looks into the American prisoner of war camps in the Midwest - where German soldiers were held right next door to many German immigrants and first generation Americans who still had strong ties to Germany. 

NOVELLA COLLECTIONS
Where Treetops Glisten (2014)* by Tricia Goyer, Cara Putman, and Sarah Sundin - a heartwarming, Christmas-themed collection set in WWII

What other Christian WWII novels do you recommend?

Susan May Warren's "Nightingale"

Susan May Warren's Nightingale is a tale of grace and forgiveness.  Esther, a nurse and single mother, is trapped by a sin she committed, trying to atone for it, and unable to feel clean again; Peter, a surgeon, was trapped in a war and is now held prisoner by the side with which he best associates.  They meet through letters first, after Peter tries to save her fiancé Linus as he lay wounded on the battlefield.  Linus passes a letter written to Esther for Peter to mail, and through this strikes up a connection with Esther, who writes back for more details.  Over the letters their friendship grows, though their faults and secrets are hidden until they finally meet in person. 

Warren has a fairly poetical style of writing, which is a nice change after many novels with a more straightforward style.  However, I tend to read quickly - sometimes too quickly - so I occasionally lost track of exactly what was happening due largely to the writing.  There is also a fair amount of jumping back and forth with memories, so it took a moment or two to figure out where I was in the story - present or past. 

This is a mature novel - not that there are scenes of steamy passion, but that it deals with hard subjects, such as a fallen woman trying to make things right.  So many of the characters, from Esther to the wounded soldiers to even Peter at times, lack hope.  And if one lacks hope, how much faith can one have left?  For "faith is being sure of what you hope for and certain of what you do not see" (Hebrews 11:1).  Esther does not believe that she can attain forgiveness for her actions, and so many of the soldiers believe there is no life for them anymore, crippled as they are.  They have lost both hope and faith.  The characters are very flawed, but Jesus came to save such souls as these; His grace proves sufficient. 

Prior to reading this novel, I had not known that during WWII there were prisoner of war camps in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Iowa, where the German soldiers were held, nor did I give much thought to what happened when the Russians occupied East Germany.

This was a good story, with less-than-well-known but fascinating history behind it, but it is not an easy read - not in the subject matter nor in the writing style.  Nightingale demands one's full attention.  4 out of 5 stars